HOME SERVICE MATCH / HOMEOWNER RESOURCES
Roof repair estimates: a homeowner’s comparison checklist
Use the free quote comparison worksheet ↓
Compare scope, exclusions and warranties before choosing a roofing proposal.
Before you request estimates
Gather the roof age if known, past repairs, material or warranty records, and dates of visible symptoms. Photographs taken from a safe ground-level position may help. Describe observations rather than diagnosing the source of a leak.
Ask every contractor the same questions
Which exact areas will be inspected and repaired? What materials and flashing work are included? Is cleanup and debris removal included? Who handles permits if required? What happens if hidden deterioration is discovered? Request written answers so estimates can be compared fairly.
Make a simple comparison sheet
Use columns for contractor, proposed work, exclusions, total quoted amount, change-order process, timing, payment milestones and warranty. A lower number may cover less work. Ask for clarification before comparing unlike scopes.
Before you accept
Verify the provider’s identity, relevant local credentials and insurance. Read the scope, cancellation provisions and warranty exclusions. Keep your records. Do not climb on the roof yourself to validate a proposal.
Explore the roofing planning page →
Planning information only. Home Service Match is an independent pilot, not a contractor. Service requests can be submitted for review. Quotes, booking and contractor matching are not guaranteed.
Compare up to three written estimates
Enter the details from your proposals, then download your comparison as a CSV file. Entries stay in this browser tab and are not submitted to Home Service Match. Download before closing the page; this worksheet does not save your entries.
| Compare | Quote 1 | Quote 2 | Quote 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contractor and credential check | |||
| Repair area and proposed scope | |||
| Materials and flashing included | |||
| Hidden damage / change-order terms | |||
| Permit responsibility | |||
| Cleanup and disposal | |||
| Total quoted price | |||
| Payment milestones | |||
| Start and completion window | |||
| Workmanship / material warranty | |||
| Exclusions and unanswered questions |
Check the contractor before comparing prices
Use our NYC and New Jersey contractor-check guide to find the appropriate official lookup.